Every year, there are overrated players in fantasy baseball that keep starting on someone’s team and fail to produce. This year, I speak from experience, as one of these guys is Nick Swisher.
I have Swisher on one of my fantasy teams, and I admit, I start him almost every day. Despite his power numbers being down, and despite that awful strikeout rate, he is in there all the time. I keep thinking he’ll get hot. Surely this guy who hit 35 home runs last year will turn it on and start tearing up the league. Couple that with me being an Oakland A’s fan, and you’ve got a recipe for fantasy disaster.
But it’s time I take a step back from my own fantasy team and look at the big picture here. Swisher is eligible at first base and outfield, so his value is in his versatility. But, should it be? Outfield and first base are both extremely deep positions. Value in those positions should come from the numbers they put up!
With a .256 batting average, 14 home runs, and 56 RBI, he’s not exactly at the top of the board in any standard fantasy category. The things he does give you are walks (leads the AL) and on-base percentage. If your league counts those - as mine does - there is at least a bright spot.
But in the big offensive categories, Swisher is being equaled in production by lesser-owned players like Matt Stairs (owned in less than 1 percent of ESPN fantasy leagues) and overshadowed by his own teammate, Jack Cust (owned in 4 percent of ESPN leagues).
Is he worth hanging onto? That’s up to you - and me.